We reproduce the following article from New Eastern Outlook, with thanks.
It contains details of one of the many holocausts that have been perpetrated by imperialist powers since the onset of colonialism; most of which are little known to British workers.
We have removed one sentence from the original article, however, which claimed that the perpetration of such holocausts is something intrinsically German. We must beg to differ most seriously with the author on this point.
There is nothing in the ‘culture and mindset of the German people’ that predisposes them toward committing such horrific crimes. Germany is, after all, the country that produced Beethoven, Goethe, Schiller, Hegel, Marx, Engels and Liebknecht, among others.
The many holocausts that have been perpetrated in the last 400 years – from those of the native inhabitants of the Americas and Australasia, to that of the trans-Atlantic slave trade, to those on African and Asian and even European soil – have all been carried out by imperialism in the pursuit of domination of territory and resources, and in the quest for profit.
Every imperialist power, without exception, has committed such attrocities in the past, and many continue to do so today. They were, in fact, the very bedrock of capital accumulation in Europe, America and Japan.
We must therefore conclude that holocausts are not an inexplicable abberation, attritable to this or that national culture, but an inherent feature of capitalist imperialism, which will only be done away with when that system is overthrown.
The academic approach
In 2014, after I published my report about Namibia, exposing the German ‘semi-denial’ that it had committed a holocaust in its former southwest African colony, a renowned German university sent me a letter. I paraphrase here, but the essence of the letter is kept intact:
“Dear Professor Vltchek, we are impressed by your research and your conclusions, and we would like to translate and publish your groundbreaking analyses in German language. Unfortunately, we cannot afford any payment …”
It was one of the major universities in the country, with tremendous budgets and an international reputation.
I replied, asking why, with all those scholars and academics, with PhDs and experts, they had never sent a team of experts to Namibia to investigate one of the most horrid crimes committed in the 20th century?
I wanted to know why they would suddenly want to rely on the work of a foreigner, an outsider, an internationalist who refuses to call himself an academic (since for me that is now a totally discredited term)?
The murder of the Herero and Nama people in southwest Africa by Germans was, after all, the key for comprehending what happened several decades later, in Europe itself, during the holocaust that Germany went on to commit against the jewish and Roma people.
The university never replied. I suppose they sensed that I was ‘dragging them’ into some extremely dangerous waters. They did not want to ‘be there’; they preferred the safe, calm waters, where some foreign left-wing intellectual writes something, and they translate and publish it, putting a disclaimer that this doesn’t necessarily reflects the position of their respected journal and the university.
As far as they were concerned, taboos should remain taboos, and the dunes of Namibia should be stirred only a little, for a limited intellectual discussion only. No storm, please!
An open secret
It doesn’t take rocket science to discover what I did in Namibia. There, I met common people, in slums and universities. I met UN experts and Namibian government officials. I undusted various archive documents. I consulted scholars in neighbouring South Africa.
In Africa, Namibian history is no secret. Nothing is taboo. This is what is common knowledge in Windhoek or in Cape Town in neighboring South Africa:
The Germans drove into the desert, and then exterminated, over 80 percent of the entire nation – the Herero. The Nama people lost around 50 percent of its population. The concentration and extermination camps were built; monstrous medical experiments on human beings were perpetrated.
German ‘doctors’, including those who were working on ‘the pure race doctrine’ in Namibia (the doctrine later used by the Nazis in Europe), subsequently ‘educated’ many German racist physicians, including the notorious ‘Angel of Death’ – Mengele. The most notorious doctor who experimented on human beings in Africa was Eugen Fischer.
Not surprisingly, the first German governor of the colony was the father of Hitler’s deputy, Herman Goering.
The holocaust in Africa is directly connected to the holocaust in Europe.
Almost the official, and a thousand times repeated, lie related to the birth of German Nazism – a lie that is even taught in many European schools – would easily collapse like a house of cards if Namibian history were to be closely examined. The lie, in different variations, goes something like this: “Germany, deeply humiliated after WWI, facing terrible economic crises, suddenly ran amok, got radicalised and ended up bringing extreme-right nationalist bigots to power.”
Do you recall the official western line about a ‘peaceful Germany, a land of scholars and philosophers; a nation that shocked itself and the world by suddenly turning to extreme violence and mass murder, abandoning its noble traditions’? Such reasoning would stand only if the Others (non-white, non-Europeans), were not considered as human beings.
The Namibian holocaust (but also to some extent, the mass murder that Germany committed against the people of today’s Tanzania) shows that [imperialist] Germany clearly has a history of genocidal behavior, and that it committed, in the 1930s and 1940s, on its own continent, precisely what it had been doing much earlier, in Africa.
This clearly cannot be attributed solely to the Nazis (there were no Nazis yet, during the holocaust in Africa).
Fortunately, the silence has not been complete. Two monstrous events have been compared and linked together. Sporadically, the truth about the horrors of the Namibian past has been appearing, even in the mainstream press.
On 21 October 2012, the Canadian daily newspaper, The Globe and Mail, reported:
“In the bush and scrub of central Namibia, the descendants of the surviving Herero live in squalid shacks and tiny plots of land. Next door, the descendants of German settlers still own vast properties of 20,000 hectares or more. It’s a contrast that infuriates many Herero, fuelling a new radicalism here.
“Every year the Herero hold solemn ceremonies to remember the first genocide of history’s bloodiest century, when German troops drove them into the desert to die, annihilating 80 percent of their population through starvation, thirst, and slave labour in concentration camps. The Nama, a smaller ethnic group, lost half of their population from the same persecution.
“New research suggests that the German racial genocide in Namibia from 1904 to 1908 was a significant influence on the Nazis in the second world war. Many of the key elements of Nazi ideology – from racial science and eugenics, to the theory of Lebensraum (creating ‘living space’ through colonisation) – were promoted by German military veterans and scientists who had begun their careers in Southwest Africa, now Namibia, during the genocide …”
In Windhoek, the capital of Namibia, a European expert working for the UN, a friend of mine, spoke to me, like almost everyone there, passionately, but without daring to reveal her name:
“The first concentration camps on earth were built in this part of Africa … They were built by the British empire in South Africa and by Germans here, in Namibia. Shark Island on the coast was the first concentration camp in Namibia, used to murder the Nama people, but now it is just a tourist destination – you would never guess that there were people exterminated there. Here in the center of Windhoek, there was another extermination camp …”
Acknowledging its crimes against the jews (but not always against the Roma people), Germany maintains as monuments all former concentration camps, including Buchenwald and Dachau. But there is absolutely nothing it does to honour the memory of its victims in other parts of the world, particularly Africa.
Racism is one of the essential characteristics of nazism. Isn’t it a clear expression of racism to treat the victims of the same crime differently, simply because of the colour of their skin?
Namibia taking court action
Now the Namibian people are suing Germany in a court in New York City.
It appears they have had enough. Enough of waiting, of humiliation. For years there has been no compensation to the families of the victims, and no serious compensation to the nation.
For years, the Namibian government has been negotiating at least for the return of all skulls of the local people, which were used in German laboratories and by German scientists to prove the superiority of the white race, as well as ‘subhumanness’ of other races, including the blacks.
German colonialists decapitated countless Herero and Nama people, and at least 300 heads were transported to German laboratories for ‘scientific research’. Many were later ‘discovered’ in the medical history museum of the Charite hospital in Berlin, and at Freiburg university.
Insults were added to injury. Even toay, German settlers enjoy a repulsively lavish lifestyle on land that was stolen from the Herero and Nama people. Many descendants of the victims of the Southwest African holocaust are now living in overcrowded slums.
German and other central European tourists are ‘in love with Namibia’ – with its dunes, its spectacular and pristine coast, and its white German enclaves. I asked several of them about the past. Most of them did not know and seemed uninterested in learning.
But the world may ‘discover’ the Namibian past very soon, as western imperialism is crumbling and oppressed people are rising to their feet.
Demands for compensation and acknowledgments of the horrific colonialist past are now flowing from Pakistan, India and other countries that were devastated by European racism and imperialism. The Namibian case may set the entire planet into motion, as almost the entire world has been devastated by European colonialism.
The US courts may not resolve much, but what is happening there is symbolic, and just a beginning.
AFP reported on 31 July:
“US District Judge Laura Taylor Swain presided over the one-hour hearing in a New York federal court but concluded the session by saying that she would not rule immediately. She also did not set a date for a decision.
“The German government wants the lawsuit thrown out on the grounds of state immunity from prosecution. The Herero and Nama groups are seeking reparations for the genocide of their peoples under German colonial rule …
“The Herero and Nama people brought the class-action lawsuit last year, seeking reparations over the tens of thousands killed in the massacres.”
There will be no easy victory for the Herero and Nama people. They have no lobby in the United States, and even back in Namibia they are poor. They own no international media, no international banks or corporations.
But they are right in demanding justice!
The renowned Canadian international lawyer, Christopher Black, declared for this essay:
“The European colonial powers imposed their dominance over other peoples through war and terror and committed violence on a vast scale. Their actions constitute the war crime of aggression and crimes against humanity, murder, assault and slavery.
“Many of those nations are still trying to escape and recover from the occupation and destruction imposed on them and should be compensated by those colonial powers for the damage done. Meaningless apologies are not enough.
“There is legal precedent for the requirement that the colonial powers pay reparations to those peoples as Germany had to do regarding its genocide against the jews. The determination of the amount and in what form it should be paid would be a contentious issue, but the victims of colonialism have a moral and legal right to compensation for the crimes committed against them and the lasting damage done.”
Percentage-wise, the Herero and Nama nations lost more people than any other race, nation or ethnic group, during the entire 20th century.
Without understanding what they suffered, what was done to them, there is no way to understand what took place right before and during World War II.
The entire anti-imperialist world has a clear obligation to support the cause of the Herero and Nama people in their quest for justice. Enough of ‘broken links’ and outright lies. Justice has to be the same for all.
Nations that were, or are victims of western genocides, massacres and colonialist plunder, should unite and declare loudly and clearly: “Never again!”